Margaritas, pt. 1
Having friends over yesterday evening, I wondered what I’d serve. I wanted something nice and refreshing, given the summer weather we’re having. I decided on a perennial favorite of mine, margaritas.
I tend to think of the margarita as one of two drinks. The first, is the traditional limeade-y mixed drink served on the rocks in sombrero-shaped margarita glasses. The second is a stronger cocktail version served straight up in a cocktail glass. I like both, but since the former is most people’s idea of a margarita let me start there.
For a well-made traditional Tex-Mex margarita, I’m not a purist about type of tequila (one can spend lots of money, if one wants, but Cuervo or Sauza Gold are fine with me), but I insist that the drink be made with fresh lime juice. Like I’ve said, making a margarita with sour mix is like making a screwdriver with Tang. Squeezing the limes means a bit more work, but the difference is immeasurable. It’ll take a lot of limes, too, maybe 10 or more for a pitcher, so find an affordable source. I get mine either at Hispanic markets/produce stands, at Chinatown, or at Haymarket, where you can get ten for a dollar instead of one for 75 cents.
The recipe I use is adapted from a Rick Bayless recipe. The trick is soaking the ingredients with lime zest (see photo), which gives a nice depth of flavor. His recipe is quite strong, so I highly recommend taking my proportions (which have half the alcohol), if you don’t want to be knocked on your ass. Trust me on this.
Margaritas on the Rocks
Adapted from Rick Bayless’s Mexican Kitchen
makes one pitcher (8 cups)2 1/2 c. tequila
1/2 c. Grand Marnier
1 1/2 c. (heaping) fresh lime juice
grated zest of 4 limes
1 c. sugar
3 c. water
Lime wedges, garnish
Coarse salt (I use kosher salt) for rimsIn a large non-metal bowl, combine all ingredients except garnish and stir to dissolve sugar. Cover and refrigerate for a few hours to steep. Strain into serving pitcher. The margaritas are ready to serve on the rocks, in glasses rimmed with salt, as your guests desire.
Can you use Cointreau or an other orange liqueur? Certainly, and I often do depending on what I have available, but I think the brandy notes of the Grand Marnier work best. In any case, stick to the twenty-dollar a bottle rule and avoid the cheap triple sec if you can.
The homemade version of the margarita, done right, is such a wonderful, sublime drink that it puts to shame much of what Boston bars and restaurants serve under the name. In fact, I almost never order the drink out.
That’s a good idea to use the lime zest. I’ve never tried that. I bet that allows the extremely high alcohol to juice ratio.
For a decent margarita out, I head to Cottonwood, but they’re really expensive. I find that I don’t really enjoy the ones at Cactus Club despite rave reviews from other people.
the difference to me between “gold” and 100% agave tequila is pretty significant, in margaritas or straight. You don’t have to go pricier than Hornitos.
Don’t mind me though, I’m a cocktail upstart